The Hornsby Shire Council’s involvement with individuals claiming GuriNgai heritage has sparked significant controversy, as allegations of fraud and cultural misappropriation have come to light. These claims, compounded by the recent withdrawal of state funding for the Westleigh Park redevelopment project, have intensified scrutiny on the Council’s dealings and the legitimacy of the GuriNgai’s involvement.
Allegations of Fraud and Cultural Misappropriation
The Aboriginal Community assert that individuals such as Tracey Howie, Laurie Bimson, and others claiming GuriNgai descent are not genuinely Aboriginal. The following points highlight key allegations:
- Invented Heritage: The GuriNgai identity is alleged to have been created by Warren Whitfield around 2001. This identity has been used by non-Aboriginal individuals to gain financial and cultural advantages.
- Conflict of Interest: Archaeologist Dr. Michael Bennett, who has worked closely with the GuriNgai claimants, has a long-standing, undisclosed relationship with them. This relationship has raised concerns about the integrity of his reports and recommendations.
- Misrepresentation: Individuals like Tracey Howie and Laurie Bimson are accused of adopting Aboriginal titles such as ‘Auntie’ and ‘Uncle’ without legitimate cultural or ancestral ties. These titles have been used to gain credibility and influence within the Council and the broader community.
Aboriginal Heritage Study
In 2018, Hornsby Shire Council initiated a comprehensive heritage study aimed at updating data on Aboriginal sites and places. The study intended to:
- Update Data: Provide current information on known Aboriginal sites.
- Recognize Cultural Values: Broaden the recognition of Aboriginal cultural heritage beyond site-based values.
- Ongoing Consultation: Establish mechanisms for ongoing consultation with local Aboriginal people about their heritage.
However, the study’s credibility has been questioned due to the involvement of Dr. Michael Bennett, who has previously produced reports supporting the GuriNgai’s contested claims. His 2008 report, which linked Tracey Howie to historical Aboriginal figures without solid evidence, is particularly controversial.
Government and Community Reactions
Federal, state, and local governments have made efforts to distance themselves from the GuriNgai group. Publications such as an article in the Daily Telegraph have critically examined the GuriNgai’s claims, labelling them as historical fiction. Despite this, Hornsby Shire Council has continued to engage with the GuriNgai, furthering public discontent.
Implications for Westleigh Park and Beyond
The controversy has significant implications for the Westleigh Park development and other council initiatives:
- Erosion of Trust: The community’s trust in the Council has been severely undermined by these allegations. The perception of mismanagement and favoritism could hinder future projects and collaborations.
- Cultural Harm: The misappropriation of Aboriginal culture and titles by non-Aboriginal individuals is seen as deeply harmful and disrespectful to genuine Aboriginal communities.
- Legal and Ethical Accountability: There may be calls for legal investigations into the Council’s dealings with the GuriNgai claimants to ensure accountability and transparency.
Moving Forward
To restore trust and ensure the integrity of its projects, Hornsby Shire Council needs to take decisive actions:
- Conduct Independent Investigations: An independent review of the Council’s dealings with the GuriNgai claimants and the heritage study should be conducted to uncover any potential misconduct.
- Enhance Transparency: Implement stricter transparency measures in awarding contracts and conducting heritage studies to prevent conflicts of interest.
- Engage Genuine Aboriginal Representatives: Ensure that future consultations and projects involve recognized and authentic Aboriginal representatives to respect and preserve true cultural heritage.
For more detailed information on the situation, refer to the Hornsby Shire Council’s official news release here.
Further Reading:
A Long Con, Gone on Too Long. 
Leave a comment